Inquiry:
Who were the sons of Heman? 1 Chronicles 25:4 lists fourteen sons. 2 Chronicles 29:14 lists two sons, neither of them from the list in the previously mentioned text. Is there a contradiction?
Response:
It is not uncommon to know more than one person by the same name. Off the top of my head, I can think of 6 people with the name John whom I know. Most of them have children, but the names of the children are varied, as are the number of children. Is that a contradiction?
It should be noted that one of the texts given by the questioner is in 1 Chronicles and the other is found in 2 Chronicles. Why is that important? These texts record different parts of Israel’s history.
1 Chronicles 25 lists the captains of the host (Levites) in the days of David, and identifies Heman as the king’s seer (v 5).
2 Chronicles 29 is not a record of the days of David, but the days of Hezekiah (v 1). This Heman is also a Levite, but cannot be the same man recorded in 1 Chronicles. The two are separated by several generations.
There is no contradiction.
Links: YouVersion | GROW magazine
Return to the article archive
